UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
SCHEDULE 14A
Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a Party other than the Registrant x
Check the appropriate box:
¨ | Preliminary Proxy Statement | |
¨ | Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2)) | |
¨ | Definitive Proxy Statement | |
x | Definitive Additional Materials | |
¨ | Soliciting Material Pursuant to §240.14a-12 |
COMMONWEALTH REIT
(Name of the Registrant as Specified In Its Charter)
CORVEX MANAGEMENT LP
KEITH MEISTER
RELATED FUND MANAGEMENT, LLC
RELATED REAL ESTATE RECOVERY FUND GP-A, LLC
RELATED REAL ESTATE RECOVERY FUND GP, L.P.
RELATED REAL ESTATE RECOVERY FUND, L.P.
RRERF ACQUISITION, LLC
JEFF T. BLAU
RICHARD OTOOLE
DAVID R. JOHNSON
JAMES CORL
EDWARD GLICKMAN
PETER LINNEMAN
JIM LOZIER
KENNETH SHEA
EGI-CW HOLDINGS, L.L.C.
DAVID HELFAND
SAMUEL ZELL
(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement, if other than the Registrant)
Payment of Filing Fee (Check the appropriate box):
x | No fee required. | |||
¨ | Fee computed on table below per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11. | |||
(1) | Title of each class of securities to which transaction applies:
| |||
(2) | Aggregate number of securities to which transaction applies:
| |||
(3) | Per unit price or other underlying value of transaction computed pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 0-11 (set forth the amount on which the filing fee is calculated and state how it was determined):
| |||
(4) | Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction:
| |||
(5) | Total fee paid:
| |||
¨ | Fee paid previously with preliminary materials. | |||
¨ | Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing. | |||
(1) | Amount Previously Paid:
| |||
(2) | Form, Schedule or Registration Statement No.:
| |||
(3) | Filing Party:
| |||
(4) | Date Filed:
|
The Choice
Is Clear Vote the GOLD
Consent Card
February 27, 2014
ATTENTION
COMMONWEALTH
REIT
SHAREHOLDERS
The
Time
To
Act
Is
Now
The Consent Solicitation To Remove The Current Board
Must
Be
Concluded
No
Later
Than
March
20
Please
Sign,
Date
And
Return
The
GOLD
Consent
Card
Today
To Ensure Your Vote Is Counted By The March 20 Deadline
A Non-vote Is A Vote To Retain The Current Underperforming Board
|
2
The Choice Is Clear
The Case for Change Now
Corvex and Related are undertaking this consent solicitation to remove the entire
Board of Trustees
of
CommonWealth
REIT
(CommonWealth,
CWH
or
the
Company)
due
to
fundamental conflicts of interest, and to subsequently elect a highly qualified new
Board of Trustees led by Sam Zell
See footnotes on p. 10.
Corvex and Related believe removal of the current Board will unlock substantial value
for all
shareholders,
and
estimate
current
Net
Asset
Value
(4)
to
be
approximately
$35
per
share in such a scenario, 34% higher than the closing price on Feb. 25, 2014
and 51% higher than
on
Jan.
28,
2014,
the
date
we
filed
definitive
solicitation
materials
with
the
SEC
Additional information can be found at www.shareholdersforcommonwealth.com
As Chairman of CWH, Mr. Zell would bring an outstanding track record of value
creation for
the
benefit
of
all
CWH
shareholders
Sam Zell is recognized as a founding father of todays public real estate
industry after creating three of the most successful REITs in history: Equity
Office Properties Trust (EOP), Equity Residential
(EQR), and Equity LifeStyle Properties (ELS)
CWH
stock
price
plummeted
68%
during
2007-2013
(2)
while
annual
fees
paid
to
RMR
increased
40%
(3)
Barry
and
Adam
Portnoy
effectively
control
CWH
despite
owning
virtually
no
stock,
with the
fees
they
pay
themselves
through
RMR
(1)
being
their
only
meaningful
economic
interest in the Company |
The Choice
Is Clear: CWH Shareholders Can Choose Value Creation or Value
Destruction Sam Zells Unrivaled Track Record for Value Creation:
Total
Return
Performance
Zell-Chaired
REITs
vs.
CWH
vs.
RMR
Fees
(1)
3
Cumulative total returns
Zell-Chaired REITs
CWH
Variance
Timeframe
EOP
368%
103%
(265%)
7/7/1997 -
2/9/2007
EQR
422%
7%
(415%)
7/7/1997 -
2/25/2013
ELS
574%
7%
(567%)
7/7/1997 -
2/25/2013
($100)
$0
$100
$200
$300
$400
$500
$600
$700
$800
(100%)
0%
100%
200%
300%
400%
500%
600%
700%
800%
1997
2000
2003
2006
2009
2012
CWH
EOP
EQR
ELS
Cumulative RMR
Fees
EOP:
368%
CWH: 7%
EQR:
422%
ELS:
574%
1997: $791 million
(1)
Note: Total returns calculated from 7/7/1997 (the earliest date on which the Zell-chaired
REITs and CWH were all public) to 2/25/2013 (last trading day before Corvex and
Related first publicly announced their intent to effect change at CWH in their initial 13-D filing
with the SEC). Total returns assume the dividends of each companys shares are reinvested
in the companys stock.
(1)
2013 RMR fees reflect annualized YTD 9/30/2013 figures. Q3 2013 RMR fees include
fees paid by Select Income REIT, of which CWH owns 44% of the outstanding common shares,
to make the figure comparable to historically disclosed figures.
Sources: Company filings, SNL
Cumulative
RMR
fees
since |
4
The Choice Is Clear
The Case for Removal: Abysmal Performance
While
the
stock
price
plummeted
68%
during
2007-2013
(1)
,
annual
fees
paid
to
RMR,
the
external
manager
wholly-owned
by
Barry
and
Adam
Portnoy,
increased
40%
(2)
,
as
RMRs
fees
are
linked
primarily
to
the
size
of
the
Company
rather
than
to
profitability
for
shareholders
Over
the
1
year,
2
years,
3
years,
5
years,
and
10
years
ended
February
25,
2013
(3)
,
the stock
price declined -17%, -45%, -43%, -45%, and -53%,
respectively The
Portnoys
effectively
control
CWH
despite
owning
virtually
no
stock,
with
the
fees
they
pay
themselves through RMR being their only meaningful economic interest in the
Company CWHs performance record is abysmal by almost any metric over any
relevant time period, in our view, but all the while the Portnoys have
continued with impunity to line their pockets
Shareholders can now take back CommonWealth, choose a new, truly
independent Board led by Sam Zell, and unlock the substantial value trapped as
a result of CWHs conflicted external management structure
(1)
Assumes 2013 share price as of 2/25/2013, last trading day before Corvex and
Related first publicly announced their intent to effect change at CWH in their initial 13-D
filing with the SEC.
(2)
RMR
fees
paid
per
CWH
public
filings
include
Select
Income
REIT,
of
which
CWH
owns
44%
of
the
outstanding
common
shares.
YTD
9/30/13
figures
annualized
to
arrive at full year 2013 estimate.
(3)
Last trading day before Corvex and Related first publicly announced their intent to
effect change at CWH in their initial 13-D filing with the SEC. |
5
The Choice Is Clear
The Portnoys
Record of Trampling on Corporate Democracy
Imposed illegal bylaw amendments and procedural hurdles, later declared invalid,
that would have made it impossible to even hold the current vote, even
though this right has been plainly granted by CWHs Declaration of
Trust since 1986 Secretly attempted to manipulate state lawmakers into
changing the Maryland Unsolicited Takeover
Act
via
an
11
hour
amendment
to
eliminate
the
right
to
hold
this
vote
Spent nearly $30 million of shareholders
money on a year-long litigation process in a brazen
campaign to systematically deprive shareholders of their right to a fair vote
Reinstated Trustee Joseph Morea after he received the vote of only 14% of the
outstanding shares at the 2013 annual meeting
Effected a massively dilutive equity offering priced at less than 50% of book
value, increasing share count by 41%, and destroying $6 per share of value,
in our view
Opted into a provision of the Maryland Unsolicited Takeover Act in a misleading
attempt, later declared invalid, to try to eliminate the right to remove
Trustees without cause The Portnoys
Actions Speak Louder Than Our Words Ever Could
The
Portnoy
Board
has
gone
to
extraordinary
lengths
to
eliminate
your
right
to
simply vote on their removal, entrenching themselves at the expense of CWH
shareholders
and
protecting
RMRs
annual
$84
million
(1)
fee
stream
Over the past year, the Board:
(1)
Represents
estimate
of
2013
RMR
fees
derived
by
annualizing
YTD
9/30/2013
figures.
Q3
2013
RMR
fees
include
fees
paid
by
Select
Income
REIT,
of
which
CWH
owns
44% of the outstanding common shares, to make the figure comparable to historically
disclosed figures. th |
6
The Choice Is Clear: Independent Third Parties Agree
The Portnoys Receive an F
New York Times
The deal world remained muted this year in terms of big transactions and activity.
Despite the relative doldrums, there were still some highlights and lowlights. Here
are some of them
The
father
and
son
duo
who
head
CommonWealth
Barry
and
Adam
Portnoy
and
CommonWealths counsel at Skadden Arps showed little regard for shareholder rights,
doing
everything
in
their
power
to
prevent
Corvex
Management
and
the
Related
Companies from removing the Portnoys. The Portnoys banked on CommonWealths
unique
requirement
that
shareholders
arbitrate
all
disputes
with
the
company
to
stymie
the
two
hedge
funds.
It
didnt
work,
and
the
arbitration
panel
ruled
against
CommonWealth,
clearing
the
way
for
the
funds
to
begin
a
campaign
to
unseat
them.
The Portnoys receive an F.
Despite
Doldrums
in
Deal
Activity,
A
Few
Highlights
This
Year,
New
York
Times,
December 17, 2013 |
7
The Choice Is Clear: A New Path
Sam Zell & David Helfand Have Joined Corvex/Relateds Slate of Nominees
Mr. Zell is willing to serve as Chairman of the Board, if so appointed by the new
Board
Mr. Zell is the current Chairman of Equity Residential, Equity LifeStyle
Properties, Covanta Holding Corporation and Anixter International Inc. and
the former Chairman of Equity Office Properties Trust (formerly the largest
REIT in the U.S.) Mr. Helfand is willing to serve as CommonWealths CEO,
if so appointed by the new Board
Mr. Helfand is Co-President of Equity Group Investments and has previously
served as Executive Vice President and Chief Investment Officer of Equity
Office Properties Trust and President and CEO of Equity LifeStyle
Properties Mr. Zell and Mr. Helfand bring exceptional credentials as well as
a business philosophy that includes:
A core
operating
principle
of
aligning
interests
between
company
leadership
and
shareholders
A conviction
that
an
internal
management
structure
promotes
incentives
to
build
successful
companies
for
the
long-term
creation
of
shareholder
value,
while
external
management structures are flawed given inherent conflicts of interest
A belief
that
a
public
companys
fiduciary
responsibility
to
its
shareholders
is
paramount
Sam Zell is recognized as a founding father of todays public real estate
industry after creating three of the most successful REITs in history: Equity
Office Properties Trust (EOP), Equity Residential (EQR), and
Equity LifeStyle Properties (ELS) |
8
The Choice Is Clear
CommonWealth Shareholders Have a Choice Between Two Paths
The Portnoys
path of conflicted external management, value destruction, and
the absence of accountability, with which CWH shareholders are all too familiar
OR
Sam Zells path of aligned internal management and accountability that fosters
the
incentives
critical
to
building
a
successful
company
focused
on
the
long-
term creation of shareholder value
As
shown
in
the
chart
on
page
3,
even
including
dividends
paid
on
CWH
stock
(1)
,
CWH
shareholders experienced a cumulative total return of a mere 7% over a nearly
16-year span
(2)
during
which
time
CWH
paid
RMR
approximately
$800
million
(3)
in
fees
In a glaring contrast, Sam Zell's track record speaks for itself: Mr. Zell
created 3 of the most successful REITs in history
As shown in the chart on page 3, we believe Mr. Zell's chairmanship of EOP, EQR,
ELS has unquestionably maximized value for shareholders over the same
16-year period in which CWH generated 7% returns
The
Time
to
Act
is
NOW
Vote
the
GOLD
Card
Today
A
Non-vote
is
a
Vote
for
the
Portnoys
Shareholders finally have an ability to choose Value Creation over Value
Destruction Dividends are assumed to have been reinvested in CWH stock. From 7/7/1997 (the earliest date
on which the Zell-chaired REITs and CWH were all public) to 2/25/2013 (last trading day before Corvex and Related first publicly
announced their intent to effect change at CWH in their initial 13-D filing with the SEC.). 2013 full year RMR fees derived
by annualizing YTD 9/30/2013 figures. Q3 2013 RMR fees include fees paid by Select Income REIT, of which CWH owns 44% of the
outstanding common shares, to make the figure comparable to historically disclosed figures.
(1)
(2)
(3) |
9
The Choice Is Clear
Voting Instructions
The
Time
to
Act
is
Now
Please
Sign,
Date
and
Return
the
GOLD
Consent
Card
Today
A Non-vote is a Vote for the Portnoys
Place
your
vote
now
to
remove
the
entire
Board
of
Trustees
Please
note
that
internet
voting
is
NOT
available
-
Shareholders
must
sign,
date
and
return the
GOLD
Consent Card in the pre-paid return envelopes provided
If
you
need
assistance
in
executing
your
GOLD
consent
card
or
placing
your
vote,
please
call our proxy solicitor:
D.F. King & Co., Inc., at (800) 714-3313
Without complete removal, the remaining Trustees would be able to unilaterally
reinstate a removed Trustee as they did just last year or fill vacancies on the Board
without input from the true owners of the company the shareholders |
10
Footnotes
Footnotes to p. 2
(1)
RMR is CWHs external manager, owned 100% by Barry and Adam Portnoy. (2)
Assumes 2013 share price as of 2/25/2013, last trading day before Corvex and Related first publicly
announced their intent to effect change at CWH in their initial 13-D filing with the SEC. (3)
2013 RMR fees reflect annualized YTD 9/30/2013 figures. Q3 2013 RMR fees include fees paid by
Select Income REIT, of which CWH owns 44% of the outstanding common shares, to make the
figure comparable to historically disclosed figures. (4)
Represents estimate of private market value of all properties owned by CWH as disclosed in 9/30/13
10-Q filing, adjusted for recent asset sales reported in the media. Additional detail
behind our NAV estimate is provided on page 71 of Corvex and Relateds Updated
Presentation to Shareholders, The Case for Change Now at CWH, February 13, 2014. This
presentation has been filed with the SEC and can also be found at www.shareholdersforcommonwealth.com.
|
11
Disclaimer
Additional Information Regarding the Solicitation
The following persons are participants in connection with the solicitation of
CommonWealth REIT shareholders: Corvex Management LP, Keith Meister,
Related
Fund
Management,
LLC,
Related
Real
Estate
Recovery
Fund
GP-A,
LLC,
Related
Real
Estate
Recovery
Fund
GP,
L.P.,
Related
Real
Estate
Recovery Fund, L.P., RRERF Acquisition, LLC, Jeff T. Blau, Richard OToole,
David R. Johnson, James Corl, Edward Glickman, Peter Linneman, Jim Lozier,
Kenneth Shea, EGI-CW Holdings, L.L.C., David Helfand and Samuel Zell. Information regarding the participants in the solicitation and a
description
of
their
direct
and
indirect
interests,
by
security
holdings
or
otherwise,
to
the
extent
applicable,
is
available
in
the
definitive
solicitation
statement filed with the SEC on January 28, 2014 and Supplement No. 1 thereto filed
on February 13, 2014. This presentation does not constitute either an offer to sell or a
solicitation of an offer to buy any interest in any fund associated with Corvex Management LP
(Corvex) or Related Fund Management, LLC (Related). Any such offer would
only be made at the time a qualified offeree receives a confidential offering memorandum and
related subscription documentation. The information in this presentation is based on publicly available information about CommonWealth
REIT (the Company). This document includes certain forward-looking statements,
estimates and projections prepared with respect to, among other things, general economic and market conditions, changes in
management, changes in the composition of the Companys Board of Trustees, actions of the Company
and its subsidiaries or competitors, and the ability to implement business strategies and plans
and pursue business opportunities. Such forward-looking statements, estimates, and projections reflect various
assumptions concerning anticipated results that are inherently subject to significant uncertainties
and contingencies and have been included solely for illustrative purposes, including those
risks and uncertainties detailed in the continuous disclosure and other filings of the Company, copies of which are
available on the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission website at www.sec.gov/edgar. No
representations, express or implied, are made as to the accuracy or completeness of such
forward-looking statements, estimates or projections or with respect to any other materials herein. Corvex and Related
may buy, sell, cover or otherwise change the form of their investment in the Company for any reason at
any time, without notice, and there can be no assurances that they will take any of the actions
described in this document. Corvex and Related disclaim any duty to provide any updates or changes to
the analyses contained in this document, except as may be required by law. Shareholders and
others should conduct their own independent investigation and analysis of the Company.
Except where otherwise indicated, the information in this document speaks only as of the date set forth on the cover page.
Permission to quote third party reports in this presentation has been neither sought nor obtained. Corvex
Management
LP
and
Related
Fund
Management,
LLC
have
filed
a
definitive
solicitation
statement
with
the
Securities
and
Exchange
Commission
(the
SEC)
to
(1)
solicit
consents
to
remove
the
entire
board
of
trustees
of
CommonWealth
REIT
(the
Removal
Proposal),
and
(2)
elect
a
s
late
of
new
trustees
at
a
special
meeting
of
shareholders
that
must
be
promptly
called
in
the
event
that
the
Removal
Proposal
is
successful.
Investors
and security holders are urged to read the definitive solicitation statement and
other relevant documents because they contain important information
regarding
the
solicitation.
The
definitive
solicitation
statement
and
all
other
relevant
documents
are
available,
free
of
charge,
on
the
SECs
website
at
www.sec.gov. |